I’m finding conversations about artificial intelligence increasingly difficult. Maybe that shouldn’t surprise me. AI touches some deeply held beliefs about learning, expertise, academic integrity, creativity, work, and even what it means to be human. When conversations move from opinions into personal beliefs and professional identity, they become much harder.
It reminded me of MVCC’s Psychology of Difficult Conversations Core Workshop from several years ago. One deceptively simple question from that work seems particularly relevant as we approach more conversations about AI: What’s my goal here?
If the goal is to convince someone that AI is transformative, we’ll probably find evidence supporting that position. If the goal is to demonstrate that AI threatens learning, there is plenty of evidence for that, too.
In fact, some emerging research is validating concerns I hear from faculty and staff. I’ve been seeing more rigorous peer-reviewed studies that draw an important distinction between performance and learning. Students can produce better work with AI without necessarily learning more. One large study of high school mathematics found that students using unrestricted AI performed significantly better during practice but subsequently performed worse than students who had not used AI when the technology was removed. Importantly, students using an AI tutor designed with learning guardrails largely avoided that penalty.
Another recent experiment offers an intriguing counterpoint. Students who first developed ideas independently, then worked with AI, and finally made their own decisions performed better on a subsequent unaided creative task than both unrestricted AI users and students who never used AI.
In other words, both sides may be seeing something real. AI can allow students to bypass the productive struggle required to develop knowledge and judgment. It can also extend human capability in extraordinary ways when thoughtfully incorporated into learning.
I recently watched a Netflix documentary, The AI Doc: Or How I Became an Apocaloptimist, that captured this tension beautifully. The first third delved deeply into how AI could go horribly wrong. The next explored possibilities for abundance beyond anything we can imagine. The final third wrestled with an uncomfortable realization: both futures are embedded in the same technology and inherently intertwined with one another.
Perhaps there’s a lesson there for us — perhaps both bitter and better. I’ve shared my appreciation for the Positive BANI framework, which supports the value of becoming more neuroflexible and developing our capacity to adapt our thinking as conditions change. I’ve also mentioned the importance of negative capability, the ability to remain in uncertainty and ambiguity without rushing toward an answer simply to relieve the discomfort. That human-centered adaptability is central to the institutional response to disruption I’ve been exploring.
AI may be giving us an opportunity to practice both. I see some encouragement in our new AI Design Team. People are coming to the table with different experiences and perspectives, yet there seems to be recognition of both sides of the AI coin and a shared desire to help MVCC get this right. Which brings me back to that Difficult Conversations Core Workshop. What’s our goal here?
Surely, it isn’t to simply win an argument about AI. Our goal is to challenge and support students so they genuinely learn, develop independent judgment, and leave MVCC prepared to thrive in a world increasingly shaped by AI. It’s about preserving what matters most about education while having the courage and curiosity to explore what might make it better.
We don’t have to agree on everything to begin there.
And perhaps that is exactly where the conversation needs to start.
If you have any questions or comments on this post, please contact me directly at presblog@mvcc.edu

